White Buffalo Pub and Pizza Co.

Sara Clare

a month ago

Absolutely delicious pizza!! The poor woman behind the bar was the only worker out front and she handled it like a boss!! She was so nice! Possibly one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had!

Campbell Haug

a month ago

White Buffalo is amazing!! It never disappoints. We have been in there many times for their pizza which is amazing, but recently we went in to get some pizza dough for homemade pizzas at home. They were going to give us a ball of dough, but even better, we got some fresh pizza dough they had just pre baked that morning so it was ready to go. It made pizza night 20x better to have their delicious crust!!

Ashley Brake

6 months ago

2nd time visit to White Buffalo Pizza did not disappoint. It was exactly how I remembered it! My husband and I had our first big family vacation in Grand Lake 7 years ago. We took our son who was 6 at the time to Colorado from a previous coworker recommendation who raved about this cute little fishing town. She also happened to mention White Buffalo Pizza and how delicious it was. Well 7 years ago, that was our first visit and our first dinner when we got to our destination. This past week was our second. This time bringing our now 7 year old daughter who I was pregnant with at the time and our now 13 year old son, along with my parents. White Buffalo Pizza was just what we remembered and loved. And of course it was our first meal this trip! We will always recommend this place and visit it when we vacation to Grand Lake Colorado! It’s a must for us!

Gabrielle Loewen (GlowGrl)

4 months ago

I had such a great experience with White Buffalo Pub & Pizza Co. I called ahead to ask about bringing my dog, and the woman on the phone was incredibly kind and accommodating. She let me know I could come in briefly to pay for my to-go order, which I really appreciated. While I waited outside, she even brought out water for my dog, which was such a thoughtful touch. And the pizza—absolutely amazing. I’ve never been a big fan of artichoke pizza, but theirs completely changed my mind. It was genuinely one of the best pizzas I’ve had. I would definitely recommend this place to others and will absolutely be coming back!

Rochelle Wentz

2 months ago

We had our dog with us, so ordered at the counter. We wanted to eat outside, so the bartender very kindly offered to open an umbrella for us at the picnic table. Both he and the wait staff who delivered our pizza to us were very friendly. The pizza was really good, too. A great dining experience.